Although
somewhat melodramatic, Edward Tufte makes some pretty solid points regarding
the overuse, and probably misuse, of PowerPoint in corporations and schools. I had never thought of it like this, but Mr.
Tufte points out that through the use of fragmented slides in PowerPoint, we
are teaching the Youth of America how to “formulate client pitches and infomercials”. Although this may actually be useful to help
them make some money, it’s probably not effective in teaching them how to write
a report or story, or even string together coherent thoughts. The most important point Mr. Tufte makes
though is that “rather than supplementing a presentation, it has become a
substitute”, which I think is extremely accurate. I don’t think PowerPoint is a bad thing, it
can be really useful and effective, but it needs to supplement what is being
said, not actually “be” what is being
said. I’m just as guilty of this as the
next person, but as they say, “The acknowledgement of our weakness is the first
step in repairing our loss." (Thomas Kempis)
No comments:
Post a Comment